"Kelly and Chris Packed Several Boxes With Books..." — GMAT® Worked Solution
Source: Official Guide for GMAT® Review, 11th Edition
Kelly and Chris packed several boxes with books. If Chris packed 60% of the total number of boxes, what was the ratio of the number of boxes Kelly packed to the number of boxes Chris packed?
(A) 1 to 6
(B) 1 to 4
(C) 2 to 5
(D) 3 to 5
(E) 2 to 3
Try it before reading on.
Step 1: Write What's Given and What's Asked
GIVEN: Chris packed 60% of the total boxes. The opening sentence adds a given without stating it: with only Kelly and Chris packing, the two of them packed all the boxes.
ASKED: the ratio of Kelly's boxes to Chris's boxes, in that order.
The order matters. Kelly to Chris and Chris to Kelly are both on the page as answer choices, and only one matches what the question asked.
Step 2: Define the Variables
Writing the definitions costs one line. Forgetting what stands for three steps later can cost the question.
Step 3: Solve for K
Substitute into :
Subtract from both sides. Writing as gives the subtraction a common denominator:
Step 4: Set Up the Ratio and Reduce
The question wants Kelly to Chris:
The cancels, and dividing by a fraction means multiplying by its reciprocal:
The answer is (E).
The Shortcut, and When It's Reasonable
Chris's 60% leaves Kelly 40%, and reduces to in one line. For a student whose practice record shows zero misses on questions they know how to do, that shortcut is a reasonable way to work. If the practice record includes misses on known questions, the written version is worth its few seconds, because every line is visible enough to check.
We write the methodical version ourselves and recommend it to any student whose practice misses include questions they knew how to do. The extra lines cost seconds. A preventable miss costs the whole question.
Why This Problem Matters
The Official Guide data shows 4% of test takers landing on (C) or (D). Both wrong choices answer a question about the total: (C) is 40 to 100, Kelly to total, and (D) is 60 to 100, Chris to total. The asked ratio is Kelly to Chris, so the computation on those paths can hold while the ratio answers a different question, the same failure mode as the population problem earlier in the episode.
The other lesson is the habit audit. Doing a problem in your head and landing right can build the belief that writing is unnecessary, and the first evidence against that belief usually arrives on a practice test. A weekly count of the misses on questions you knew how to do is the honest version of the audit, and How Writing Down More Improves Your GMAT® Score covers the habit in full.
Want the full strategy? Read: GMAT® Roots and Ratios: The Foundations-First System
From Episode 15 of Real GMAT® Problems (The GMAT® Strategy Podcast).